Tuesday, 12 April 2011

Winklevoss twins lose Facebook appeal over site idea

Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss The Winklevosses say Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg stole their idea for a social network site

A US appeals court has ruled that twin brothers who say the idea for Facebook was stolen from them by Mark Zuckerberg cannot back out of a settlement deal they made with the website.

Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss had asked in January to re-open a $65m (£42m) legal settlement signed in 2008.

The twins say Mr Zuckerberg stole their idea after he was hired by them to code their ConnectU site in 2003.

The court said it saw no reason to re-open their case against Facebook.

Facebook has rejected the brothers' claims.

"The Winklevosses are not the first parties bested by a competitor who then seek to gain through litigation what they were unable to achieve in the marketplace," three Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals judges said in the ruling.

"At some point, litigation must come to an end. That point has now been reached," the judges said.

'Stolen code'

The Winklevosses have argued that Mr Zuckerberg, who attended Harvard with them, took the code for their social networking website and launched Facebook with it in 2004.

Facebook agreed to a 2008 settlement to end "rancorous litigation" but did not admit Mr Zuckerberg had taken the twins' idea.

The Winklevosses received $20m in cash and $45m worth of stock valued at $36 per share in the deal.

"For whatever reason, they now want to back out... Like the district court, we see no basis for allowing them to do so," the judges said, referring to the settlement deal.

Jerome Falk, a lawyer representing the Winklevosses, said he disagreed with the ruling and that his legal team would file for a rehearing within the next two weeks.

"In my judgment, the opinion raises extremely significant questions of federal law that merit review by the entire Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals," Mr Falk said in a statement.

Mr Zuckerberg has always maintained that Facebook was his creation.

The lawsuit over Facebook was dramatised in the film The Social Network, which was nominated for best picture at the Oscars.

Facebook is the world's biggest social network with more than 500m users, and Mr Zuckerberg is one of the world's youngest billionaires.

Sunday, 10 April 2011

AU seeks end to Libya unrest



African Union panel, due to visit Benghazi, appeals for "an immediate end to hostilities" as fighting rages in Ajdabiya.
Last Modified: 10 Apr 2011 11:31

African Union mediators on Libya have reiterated their appeal for "an immediate end to all hostilities" and proposed a transition period to adopt reforms as intense fighting continues across the country.

The committee, headed by Mauritanian President Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz, is expected to head to the opposition stronghold of Benghazi in eastern Libya later on Sunday.

The delegation also includes the leaders of Mali, Uganda, South Africa and the Democratic Republic of Congo.

A statement from the presidency said South African President Jacob Zuma said: "The committee has been granted permission by NATO to enter Libya and to meet in Tripoli with ... [Libyan leader Muammar] Gaddafi. The AU delegation will also meet with the Interim Transitional National Council in Benghazi on 10 and 11 April."

The committee said in a statement that it had decided to go along with a roadmap adopted in March, which calls for an end to hostilities, "diligent conveying of humanitarian aid" and "dialogue between the Libyan parties".

Click here to follow our Libya live blog

It also said it intended to propose "inclusive management" of a transition period aimed at adopting and setting up of "the political reforms needed to eliminate the causes of the present crisis."

Nabila Ramdani, a French journalist and Middle East expert, said the situation with regards to Libya had reached not only a military but also a political deadlock.

"It's quite worrying," she told Al Jazeera. "Unfortunately, my view about the African Union is that it will appear as not being a credible group of people to be in a position to broker a deal on behalf of [Muammar] Gaddafi.

"They're a group of dictators themselves and they won't be taken very seriously given that they're from very brutal regimes which are in many ways far worse than the Gaddafi regime."

Ajdabiya shelled

Meanwhile, opposition fighters said forces loyal to Gaddafi had killed four rebels in a battle for control of the strategic east Libyan town of Ajdabiya.

"I saw the four this morning. Their throats were slit and they were all shot through the chest and dumped on the road. Their car was also riddled with bullets," Mohammed Saad, a rebel at a checkpoint on the eastern edge of Ajdabiya, told Reuters.

Al Jazeera's Sue Turton, reporting from just north of Ajdabiya, confirmed that fighting was ongoing.


Al Jazeera's has obtained exclusive footage
showing Gaddafi forces in the battlefield

"We're seeing plumes of smoke and constant shelling ... There are pockets of Gaddafi's forces in the city."

She said she had been told that there were patients in a hospital who appeared to have been shot by sniper fire.

She described the city as something of a "ghost town" as many residents have fled since fighting erupted a few weeks ago.

On Saturday, rebels fought off an assault by Gaddafi's forces on the besieged western city of Misurata, losing up to 30 men.

Mustafa Abdulrahman, a rebel spokesman, said Saturday's fighting centred on a road to Misurata port, while NATO carried out several attacks on forces loyal to the Libyan leader.

Abdulrahman praised what he called a positive change from NATO. Rebels have complained for days that NATO has been too slow to respond to government attacks.

NATO said armoured vehicles firing on civilians had been targeted in air strikes, and that its jets had also struck ammunition stockpiles being used to resupply forces involved in the shelling of Misurata and other population centres.

A rebel who identified himself as Abdelsalem told Reuters that government troops had attacked Misurata on three fronts.

"Medical workers and rebels told me that at least 30 rebel fighters were killed," he said.

Residents fleeing

Misurata, Libya's third largest city, has been under siege by Gaddafi's forces for weeks. Rebels say people are crammed five families to a house in the few safe districts to escape weeks of sniper, mortar and rocket fire.

There are severe shortages of food, water and medical supplies and hospitals are overflowing.

Residents used boats to flee to the eastern city of Benghazi on Saturday.

"There is not a word in the dictionary to describe this. 'Disaster' is not enough," Ali Spak, the captain of one of the ships, said.

Click here for more of our special coverage

"There is very bad destruction. This man [Gaddafi] is killing his own people. There's shelling everywhere, even on the people trying to leave. People need help," one man on the boat said.

Doctors said last week that 200 people had been killed in Misurata since fighting broke out there in late February.

The Red Cross on Saturday ferried emergency medical supplies and five staff for 300 people wounded in the city.

Meanwhile, Lieutenant General Charles Bouchard, the commander of the alliance's operations in Libya, accused Gaddafi's forces of using civilians as human shields, adding to similar charges made by other Western commanders.

"We have observed horrific examples of regime forces deliberately placing their weapons systems close to civilians, their homes and even their places of worship," Bouchard said in a statement.

"Troops have also been observed hiding behind women and children. This type of behaviour violates the principles of international law and will not be tolerated."

As his troops engaged rebels in new fighting, Gaddafi made his first television appearance in five days. He was last seen on April 4.

Gaddafi smiled and pumped his fists in the air as he received an ecstatic welcome at a school in Tripoli, where women ululated and pupils chanted anti-western slogans.

?

Source:
Al Jazeera and agencies

Graffiti claims Alexandria's walls

<p>A young artist paints revolutionary slogans on an Alexandria wall</p>
Photographed by other

In recent weeks, Alexandria’s corniche has been the site of a remarkable artistic phenomenon. Young activists have used graffiti to turn walls facing the sea into a long, decorated banner that assesses a new Egypt. The drawings, paintings and writing depict political demands that show Egypt’s revolution is not yet finished.

“It’s not art for art’s sake. It’s politics. We are telling people that the revolution is continuing and our demands still haven’t been met,” said Ranwa Youssef, a graduate student of fine arts who collaborated with her colleagues to translate political messages into art.

Egypt’s second largest city was a cornerstone to the massive protests that led to the resignation of former President Hosni Mubarak. Following his departure, Egypt's Supreme Council of Armed Forces (SCAF) took charge of the country after hailing the people’s revolt. But for the artists, this praise hasn't translated into a political commitment to abstain from despotic practices of the former regime. SCAF is accused of engaging in torture and arresting political activists.

On a wall near the famous Bibliotheca Alexandria, slogans read "Release all the political prisoners," "End state of emergency," and "The revolution is continuing."

Youssef said that after the 25 January revolution, Alexandria's artists became more organized.

"During the revolution, people used to hide in order to scribble graffiti because they were afraid of the pro-Mubarak thugs and the secret police. Now it's different. We engage in public discussions with ordinary people," she said.

People wrote on walls during the revolution to deliver political messages and call for continued protesting. Some slogans, for instance, mocked Mubarak for his wealth.

"Lied, is lying, will lie," was one slogan following a speech given by Mubarak. Written in black, with style, the slogan appeared on the wall of the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Alexandria, only meters away from Qaed Ibrahim mosque, the site of the anti-Mubarak protests in the coastal city.

Some historians trace graffiti back to the Ancient Egyptians, whose drawings on walls and rocks are considered to be among the world's oldest graffiti. Egyptologist Alexander Peden wrote about the practice in his extensive book on graffiti of Pharaonic Egypt.

But in modern times, ruling authorities viewed graffiti as more pollution than art. In 2006, the European Parliament stated, “More attention should be paid to preventing and removing dirt, litter, (and) graffiti.”

In modern Egypt, graffiti has not been used as a political tool until recently. The former regime systematically arrested young activists who failed to hide while making graffiti.

Safwan Mohamed, a 29-year-old political activist who was arrested while trying to write on walls in Alexandria, said that creating graffiti had serious consequences. In 2010, Mohamed launched a graffiti campaign called "Ana" (Me), aimed at combating the presumed ascension of Gamal Mubarak to his father's office.

"It was really dangerous for anyone who thought about writing anything on the wall. Just start writing and then you are arrested and the accusation is ready -- destabilizing the regime and destroying public property," Mohamed said.

"We were using writing on the wall as a tool to tell the people that they should be aware of the inheritance project. We wrote slogans such as 'No to inheritance' and 'No to monopoly.' Now I can tell that the impact was really positive," he said.

Activists also used graffiti to call people to strike on 6 April 2008, which Facebook groups had chosen as a national day for civil disobedience against the Mubarak regime.

Both Youssef and Mohamed agree that the case of Khaled Saeed gave momentum to graffiti art in Alexandria. Saeed was allegedly beaten to death after being illegally arrested on 6 June last year by two police officers in Alexandria.

The case became a landmark in the campaign against police brutality. It also brought to life the Facebook group "We are all Khaled Saeed," which was believed to be a major player in organizing the mass anti-government protests that led to the ouster of Mubarak on 11 February.

"We used to write on the walls and asphalt political messages which indicate that we will not forget the killers of Khaled Saeed, and we will not tolerate torture," Youssef said.

"It was a success since the people were sympathizing with the case of Saeed. During the various sessions of the trial, people helped us to deliver our messages through writing on the walls," said Mohamed.

The main dilemma, he said, was that the authorities would remove the graffiti quickly, but Youssef disagreed.

"Now we are not afraid of the police and people don't see us as aliens. They perceive us as revolutionaries," she said.

However, the post-Mubarak graffiti is still in contention, Youssef said.

"During the revolution they [the Salafis] tried to remove all the graffiti that calls for a civil state. They also removed some of the paintings that portray the crescent with the cross together," she said. But in spite of the Salafi threat, residents have been enjoying the art, she said.

"By using various colors such as red, blue, black and yellow, we are trying to emphasize the artistic feature of graffiti. Why not deliver your political message in an artistic way, so people can enjoy it and interact with it?" asked Ranwa.

One mural on a wall close to the Bibliotheca Alexandria depicts a child voicing a revolutionary demand to "hold Wael Alkomy accountable." Alkomy is a notorious police officer who allegedly tortured citizens; he is also accused of killing protesters while trying to escape from a police station on 28 January, a date known as the "Day of Anger."

"We are interacting with people to tell them that we are the revolution and these drawings are part of it. These drawings tell the history of our struggle against Mubarak," Youssef said.

Military council to replace certain governors


Sun, 10/04/2011 - 12:58

<p>مئات من طلاب جامعة القاهرة، وعين شمس، والأزهر، وحلوان، ينظمون مسيرة، تنطلق من أمام جامعة القاهرة، وصولاً إلى ميدان التحرير، لينضموا إلى مئات الآلاف من المشاركين في «جمعة التطهير»، 8 أبريل 2011، تأكيداً على مطالبهم بإقالة رؤساء الجامعات، وعمداء الكليات، ووكلائهم، فضلاً عن فتح كل ملفات الفساد الإداري بالجامعات، وأخيراً، إلغاء كل العقوبات والتحقيقات التي تم توقيعها على خلفية الاعتصامات والتظاهرات الجامعية.</p>
Photographed by محمد كمال

The ruling Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) said on Saturday that it will replace some governors who came to office during the rule of deposed president Hosni Mubarak.

Major General Ismail Etman said “New governors will be announced within days. Consultations and discussions about them are still ongoing.” In a press conference Etman said that replacing senior leaders takes place in accordance with the law.

The decision came a day after a mass protest in Tahrir Square, in which tens of thousands of protesters called for the trials of Mubarak and his regime's corrupt figures, as well as the sacking of governors.

Minister of Local Development Mohsen al-Noamani said governors will be replaced in hours. The Saudi Al-Arabiya satelite news channel quoted al-Noamani as saying “new governors will be appointed in coordination with the SCAF.”

Egyptian revolutionaries have called for the collective dismissal for all governors and heads of local councils. They said that such posts should be by election rather than appointment.

Under Mubarak’s regime, governors belonged to the National Democratic Party and were retired police officers.

The media has reported some governors' administrative and financial corruption, as well as incidents of selling of state lands at lower than market prices. Prosecution received reports accusing Minya governor Ahmed Diaa Eddin and Beni Suef governor Samir Seif al-Yazal of facilitating land seizure.

Protesters have been demanding, since Mubarak's ouster on 11 February, the removal of Ismailia, Cairo and Luxor governors.

Sunday's papers: Fears of sedition, the military's laxity, Mubarak's trial

“Threats of counterrevolution,” “The greatest sedition,” “The remnants of the old regime” are catchphrases that stand out on the front pages of most newspapers. Coverage of the bloody confrontation that took place between the army and protesters before dawn on Saturday, leaving at least one killed and dozens injured, takes the lion’s share of space. While most papers dismiss the weekend’s violence as an imminent threat to the revolution’s achievements, their insights into what the situation requires is quite nuanced.

Most state-owned news outlets are content to warn against attempts aimed at “driving a wedge” between the people and the military. Most of them put the blame for the unprecedented standoff -- in which live ammunition was reportedly fired -- on “the remnants” of ousted President Hosni Mubarak’s regime.

“The 25 January revolution stands on two feet: the people and the army. If they lose balance, the revolution will fall and counterrevolutionary forces consisting of the corrupt remnants of the old regime will obliterate it once and for all,” writes Yasser Rizk, editor in chief of Al-Akhbar daily.

Rizk’s column, which takes up half a page, elaborately defends the Supreme Council of Armed Forces (SCAF). The writer holds that no SCAF members -- including its head Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi -- have personal ambitions for power.

“On the contrary, they [are] all concerned about people’s interests and the future of the country,” writes Risk.

Rizk confidently affirms that the military will hold trials for all corrupt leaders of the former regime including Mubarak himself. In recent weeks, SCAF has come under criticism due to its failure, up until now, to take action against Mubarak and his family despite reports about their illicit financial gains. The military also seems reluctant to try iconic figures of Mubarak’s regime, including former Shura Council Speaker Safwat al-Sherif, former People’s Assembly Speaker Fathi Sorour and Presidential Chief of Staff Zakaria Azmy. Azmy was arrested only last week.

On the other hand, the privately-owned daily Al-Shorouk offers a more sophisticated reading of the situation and refrains from taking the military’s side. In his column, managing editor Wael Qandil writes: “It was “the darkest night in Tahrir Square. What happened at dawn on Saturday lies as the most serious threat to the revolution... It shows that all parties have lost control and have become very volatile and things may explode at any time.” Qandil directs his outrage at the military, wondering why SCAF is not rushing to try stalwarts of Mubarak’s regime, dismantle the formerly ruling National Democratic Party, and abrogate the state of emergency. He goes on to reiterate an earlier demand voiced by many political forces -- that the military share power with a temporary civilian presidential council.

“What happened shows that there is a problem in the way the revolution is being managed. Therefore, SCAF should see no shame in calling upon heavy-weight politicians with strong expertise in crisis management to develop a national program that can ensure a safe transition,” says Qandil.

Addressing possible ways of moving forward, the liberal daily Wafd contends that Mubarak must stand trial. On the front page, Editor In Chief Osama Heikal sends a clear message to the military: “It is impossible to oust the president in 18 days and spend 60 days thinking of whether to try him. The situation cannot be handled with painkillers … The president’s wealth is a crucial issue that needs to be investigated and there is no way to do that without a fair trial... so why the slowness?”

Egypt's papers:

Al-Ahram: Daily, state-run, largest distribution in Egypt

Al-Akhbar: Daily, state-run, second to Al-Ahram in institutional size

Al-Gomhorriya: Daily, state-run

Rose al-Youssef: Daily, state-run, close to the National Democratic Party's Policies Secretariat

Al-Dostour: Daily, privately owned

Al-Shorouk: Daily, privately owned

Al-Wafd: Daily, published by the liberal Wafd Party

Al-Arabi: Weekly, published by the Arab Nasserist party

Youm7: Weekly, privately owned

Sawt al-Umma: Weekly, privately owned

Security beefed up around Mubarak residence


DPA
Sun, 10/04/2011 - 12:38


<p>القصر الخاص بالرئيس السابق محمد حسني مبارك، الذى بناه رجل الأعمال «حسين سالم»، الصديق المقرب للرئيس السابق، بشرم الشيخ، 4 أبريل 2011.</p>
Photographed by other
Archived

Security at the entrances and exits of South Sinai province, where the current residence of former president Hosni Mubarak is located, has been tightened, a security source told DPA.

The source said the measures were being taken in response to calls during Friday's protests to protest at Mubarak's sanctuary. Mubarak has been residing in Sharm al-Sheikh since stepping down on 11 February.

Many are warning that the heightened security will affect tourism at the resort, which has been enjoying an increase in British and Russian tourist arrivals. A tourism expert there said that North Sinai -- Sharm el-Sheikh in particular -- has restored its position as Egypt's favorite coastal destination for European, Arab and domestic visitors.

The security source said that tourist activities have been revived only up to 50% of the numbers seen in the same period in previous years.

A hotel owner in the governorate said that the security reinforcements, which started this week, will impact European tourism in particular, as European tourists like to move freely.

Muslim Brotherhood creates Facebook page


Sun, 10/04/2011 - 13:03

Photographed by other

The Muslim Brotherhood announced the creation of a Facebook page to raise awareness about its thinking and approach to change.

Observers believe the Brotherhood is seeking to use the internet as a publicity tool in the run up to Egypt's parliamentary elections, slated for September. They say the group has opted for Facebook as it is interactive and attracts an increasing numbers of users.

The Brotherhood had last week announced its intention to contest 49 percent of parliamentary seats, becoming the first political power to announce the size of its participation in the poll.

On its official website, the group said on Saturday that its Facebook page is called "Who we are and what we want". It features several video clips and articles explaining the message of the Brotherhood's founder, Hassan al-Banna.

The Brotherhood said the page also includes profiles of key Brotherhood figures from the past and present.

The group has approximately 10 websites that promote its ideas and act as news portals.

The number of Egyptian Facebook users rose during the 25 January revolution by one million. The website was used to call for protests from the beginning, and to disseminate information about what was happening.

Reports say the Brotherhood is likely to make considerable gains in the upcoming parliamentary elections.